Nelio's Nasty Sig Shop reviews-- It will reopen soon close this!

[Nelio.c]

Now in the TBT newspaper!

Every week I will try to post a Sig , made by a sig shop , and then I use that sig to make a overall review to the shop.
Ps: I will not use the sigs the shops did for me , I will post all the sigs here so you guys can see them and see the best shop in your opinion.
I will rate the shops 1 to 5 then I post some feedback.
I will base my review in 2 major points:
Originality : No one wants a default sig , am I right?
Style : The sig might me original but if sux , its a waste of time.

1 - Trash.
2 - Bad.
3 - Ok.
4 - Good.
5 - Perfect.
Easy?

(17-02-2012 04:14 PM)List of Shop reviews Wrote:  Next week: Boy Levy + Peter shop
Then then: the Signature Factory
After that: AleksGórecki's signature warehouse

________________________________________________________________________________​_____________________________
Review of chaseyum and Gimmellas siggys shop.Link

they made me this sig:
Review: First of Id like to thanks chaseyum for doing this sig, time to review.
Well the the sig shop is a bit famous these days so was watching the sigs they made and the major problem to this shop is the details, small details make a big difference , the thing is ,they dont make any details or original things, for instance the background in my sig is kinda cool in red but should be way better he it had some details like explosions , fire or something to call the atention.
In this shop some sigs may suffer with shadow too dark , or no shadows at all and they mostly only use black shadows , without white/bright shadows is hard to see where the light source is (no light source , why shadows?)
Their type of text is Ok , nothing realy good / bad here (sometimes the text is realy simple , then the sig get a step down).
Now lets talk about originaly , well should be a better sig shop if they add new, creative , original ideias to put in the sigs , some of the sigs look very very simple.
Now the overall , this is NOT A BAD shop , and I predict a bright future if they continue to improve.
My rating is : 3
________________________________________________________________________________​____________________________

Blindboylevy Shop : Click here to visit the shop
Sig he made:

So the blindboylevy shop is one of the most requested / best sig shops around , so I decided to review it.
This shop one of the best when it comes to chars editing , he knows how to make shadow with proper light source , but something about this shop isnt as good as should be , the fact that BBL sometimes makes sigs way WAY too simple , not showing all his skill.
His type of text style isnt bad at all , but has the same problem , some text's come out way to simple and that makes them come down a step.
Also some of his made sig´s look very similar ( Im not saying they are bad , but see some of his examples and you will see what im talking about)
Maybe he lacks of time and rushes to make the sigs?
Maybe sometimes he just dont have ideias?
I dont know to be honest but will give 4 to this shop, a very good place to try to get a sig.
Now, im sure if he does more original and better sigs with reach 5 very soon.
The comunity gave a overall rate of 7/10
________________________________________________________________________________​____________________________

Finally the long wait is over (for some) , this will be Magik Signature Guild REVIEW!!
First off id like to thank The Magik Signature Guild for making me a sig 2x , due some problems this took a while , sorry.

Now the review itself, the Magik Signature Guild shop is one of the most known shops around , its the shop with the biggest number of guys if im correct , this is good and bad ,since some are better than others .
Sometimes I see members doing very simple , crappy/unoriginal sigs but other times I see some of the best sigs in this forum .
Maybe its the lack of experience and skill of some members and due to that I think the number of members kinda makes this shop to come down a bit due to that.
The overall shop is good with good edits and text they also make the sigs fast and send you short period after the request but the lack in originality and nice shapes is other weakness.
If the not-so-good guys keep work I think this shop will be almost perfect shop but now I think its fair 4.

They made me this sig:

The rate for this sig is 6/10


Links:
The Magik Signature Guild - http://www.battlefieldheroes.com/en/foru...tid=234127
________________________________________________________________________________​____________________________

Notes:
Sorry for my bad english.
And keep it mind this review is based in my opinion , you may dislike it , but please keep it for yourself.

[TrickStatus]

cool ! Looking forward to this.

[mortefreetokill]

Good idea!

[CaptainShootALot]

Im looking forward for some tough signature ratings

[Nelio.c]

By the way , you guys can request a shop review here too.

[shadowbolt152]

lol'd i liek teh idea

[chaseyum]

omg the pressure of being the 1st shop and having me and gimmellas fate in my hands

[Nelio.c]

(03-12-2011 01:42 PM)chaseyum Wrote:  omg the pressure of being the 1st shop and having me and gimmellas fate in my hands

Im sure you will make it

[Kalta]

Best idea!

[GunGub]

Great Idea Nelio

[pastapipo224]

Too bad i don't have a shop atm :/

[!Torin]

Looking forward

[Pormcorn]

Derp..........
Something bothers me, but I can't tell.

[haw4]

Cool man i like your sig!

[Nelio.c]

(03-12-2011 06:49 PM)Pormcorn Wrote:  Derp..........
Something bothers me, but I can't tell.

O.o
You can tell.

[ninpro]

sick sig shop make me one
lol u are sound and a good community member thumbs up

[cantdieatm]

i rly like the idea of this
but
i dont like the part where a bad shop will get sh*tty ratings as this is most likely going to result in less requests for that sigmaker and will just slow down his improvement alot

other than that , good luck

[Nelio.c]

(03-12-2011 07:56 PM)cantdieatm Wrote:  i rly like the idea of this
but
i dont like the part where a bad shop will get sh*tty ratings as this is most likely going to result in less requests for that sigmaker and will just slow down his improvement alot

other than that , good luck

I know what you mean , I will try not to be way to "evil" and I will not rate the shops alone , I will make "[rate]this sig" threads so you guys can give your opinion about the sig and the shop.
Also if the shop doesnt want to get "rated" doesnt get rated.
One last thing , the shop can always ask for a 2nd turn , after some improvement.

[Collin]

Rate my shop. Or just me?

[ikbenjonas]

then ill choose a 4